A community campaign.

Save Our School
New Site Navigation

Home
News
The Issue
Background
Ofsted on Haywood
A Caring Community
Public Support
Press Coverage
People to Contact
What Politicians say
City Learning Centres
All about Serco
Links
Archives
Opinions

Opinions
These opinions may, or may not, have a direct relevance to the fight to save Stoke's schools.


This site is not run by anybody with formal links to Haywood. The school has
no control over the content of this site.


Top down development does not work!
A story that has relevance to our campaign.

Community engagement

Communication and Consultation?

Coincidence or what?
Gagged

A campaign website
that
airs the opinions of the community,
run by the community
for the community.

Save Our School

Big Brother has arrived in Stoke-on-Trent.
Please draw your own conclusions.

19th September 2007

Why is it that every time our attention is drawn to some act by the City Council that will affect our schools, we come away even more depressed and convinced that democracy is dead in Stoke. This particular item does not directly affect any particular school, but will affect our ability to discover the truth about what is happening in our schools.

The Council needs to be dragged (probably with many kicks and screams) into the 21st Century. It is no longer acceptable for local politics to be shrouded in mystery - the public has a right to know everything that the Council is doing, both the good bits and especially the bad bits.

The era of the Spin Doctor is past; Mr. Campbell has departed, Ms. Jo Moore was sacked. So now are we permitted to know what is going on? Maybe elswhere, but not in Stoke. Rigorous control of information is to become the norm. We were recently tipped off that Council "officers are 'not allowed' to speak directly to the media anymore and that all questions must be routed by email through the press office". Sounds O.K. - data protection and all that - until you notice that all questions must be routed by e-mail. Why? What's wrong with the good old telephone? Or face-to-face communication?

Something is rotten in the State of Stoke.

After a little digging, we found this gem:

Advert for Head of PR and Comms

A bit more research and we found this (http://www.careersforleaders.com/fullVacancy.aspx?job_id=2423):

Vacancy Details

Back to previous page
Stoke on Trent City Council Tribal
# # #
#
#
Stoke on Trent City Council 
#
Location Stoke on Trent View Job Microsite >>
Job Title Head of Public Relations & Communications
Closing Date 01/10/2007
Reference No. CFL
Salary c. £75k
Description Our success depends on your ability
 
With a massive regeneration agenda, Stoke is transforming beyond recognition. And so is Stoke-on-Trent City Council. With a new CEO and management team, it is constantly evolving. In this newly created position, you will make sure everyone knows about it immediately. It is a huge role requiring someone with big vision. Not just a seasoned PR professional, you will have substantial experience as a journalist and you will be ready to take ownership of our communications, marketing, press office and publications. You will need to take tough decisions every day and be imaginative and creative.
 
For further information and details about this opportunity please visit www.tribalresourcing.com/stoke
 
Alternatively, please contact Heather Ferguson, Tribal retained consultant on 0121 233 7700.
 
Closing date: 24th September 2007.
 
Transformation. Teamwork. Talent
Application Details If you apply for this position, please say you saw it on careersforleaders.com

So, we took them up on their invitation, and visited www.tribalresourcing.com/stoke. This is what we found:

Welcome

Dear Prospective Applicant,

Thank you for your interest in the post of Head of Public Relations and Communications at Stoke-on-Trent City Council. This is an extremely demanding job and we have put together a number of resources which we hope you will find useful in deciding whether you might be the right person to take it on. We have no doubt that the successful candidate will find it a highly satisfying challenge. There are many hard-working and talented people employed at the authority and among the elected members.They deserve a strong and motivated Communications team to help them work well together and to present a positive and effective face to the city, the government and the wider world.

Working in the Press Office at Stoke-on-Trent City Council – an Insider's View

The Head of Public Relations and Communications at Stoke-on-Trent City Council has to look simultaneously outward to the media, the electorate and Westminster and inward to the various departments and elected members. A local authority employing more than twelve thousand people in such disparate areas as Parks and Gardens, Schools, Housing and all the authority's myriad other responsibilities has a crucial need of effective internal communications. It will be up to you to ensure that the systems are in place to cope with this, electronically, verbally and on paper, and that they function to the optimum. Stoke Council house

Communication with the electorate is not all through the media. You must assess the existing channels and ensure that quarter of a million people know what their local authority is doing, why it is doing it, and be assured that they, in turn, are able effectively to voice their opinions. Historically there has been a plethora of leaflets, pamphlets and publications issuing from each council department along with posters on bus shelters. These have gone out from their authors, directly to print. The current interim regime is ending this practice and in future, all council publications will receive a final review by the Head of Public Relations and Communication before they are cleared for release.

A new citywide news magazine, Our City is currently being prepared for distribution to every household and business. This is an exciting and original joint venture which is being produced in collaboration with several other public bodies including local police and the PCT. Stoke-on-Trent City Council is the lead authority in this collective and the Head of Public Relations and Communication will have ultimate responsibility for its success.

Internal communications will also come under your purview. A new staff newsletter is in the process of being launched and there are frequent corporate e-bulletins which also require careful examination before circulation.

The eyes of Parliament are more keenly fixed on Stoke-on-Trent City Council than just about any other local authority in the country. It is vital that Westminster politicians are made to feel increasingly confident in the authority's abilities.

The most pressing day-to-day requirement for the Head of Public Relations and Communication will be in the Press Office, where you will need to be based and determinedly hands-on. This job is not about sitting behind a big desk in a well-appointed office.

Stoke's local media is typical of many English cities:

  • The Sentinel is a popular traditional local paper.
  • BBC Radio Stoke is the BBC local radio station.
  • Signal Radio is the local commercial station.
  • BBC Television has a reporter based in the BBC Radio Stoke newsroom but no permanent crew.
  • Central News visit when there is a big story to cover.

As a group, journalists working for these organisations are no more hostile or supportive than anywhere else. Make them believe that the council is more positive, more efficient and doing a better job than they had previously thought and the coverage will improve. Make a mess of things and they will exploit it.

Stoke-on-Trent City Council's Press Office has been defensive for a number of years. This is a straightforward reflection of the authority's own stance as destructive stories have rained down upon them.

In more recent times attempts have been made to change this culture. The interim communications regime has been encouraging council officers and elected members to offer up good news stories in advance about the progress the council is making and the way it is benefiting local people. This will only succeed by continual positive reinforcement. The good stories are there, but they need to found, properly researched, correctly written up and supported by the right available interviewee. When this process works the results have been good, and the media have responded well. Feedback from officers and elected members in the wake of good stories has been strong, this in turn lifts staff moral. In short a hard-working, positive and determined Press Office is giving everyone heart. Computer operator

The daily fare in the Press Office is, frankly, relentless. It is not unusual to receive calls, from The Sentinel in particular, on a dozen to twenty different stories, all of which need to be followed up and responded to, making sure that the relevant political portfolio holder is informed that a story relating to her or his department may appear.

Rebuttal is important and effective. The presence of a press officer, listening intently to an interview with a portfolio holder, concentrates the reporter's mind admirably on accuracy.

To work in Stoke-on-Trent City Council's Press Office requires significant political “nouse”. The unique coalition between Labour, the Conservative and Independent Group and the Liberal Democrats actually helps stabilise the public attitudes of key members. They are all aware of the need to speak, as far as possible, with one voice. The portfolio holders are remarkably supportive of each other in spite of political difference. However, it is of crucial importance that staff in the Press Office grasp quickly the variety of political nuance which abounds. The three main parties do not have a monopoly on representing the electorate. There are various other groupings of independents and a small number from the British National Party.

There has been an unfortunate culture of leaking by councillors and officers. Long-term disaffected individuals and those disgruntled over a single issue are almost certainly present in any local authority. Leaks will never be completely stopped but dissenting voices can be drowned out by sheer weight of positive comment. There is sufficient scope within an authority of this size to put out two or three worthwhile good news stories a day. It is the Press Office's job to encourage those who know about them to come forward, to recognise them for what they are and to give them such impetus that the journalists cannot ignore them. This is already beginning to happen.

To be a success in the Press Office at Stoke-on-Trent City Council experience in local government and knowledge of the area would be advantageous. Experience of a busy newsroom, toughness and an understanding of what journalists want are indispensable. Strong-minded professionals only need apply.

So what can the new Head of Public Relations and Communications expect to gain from taking up the challenge? It is not one for the faint-hearted, but the rewards of success will be significant. Make the ‘worst-rated council in the country' recognised as a beacon of good-practice and you yourself will be highly-prized. This is a rare opportunity to “make a name and make a difference” and with plans in place, we are well advanced and already on the way to turn our one star CPA rating in 05/06 into three stars for 06/07 and 07/08.

Save Our School
Democracy in Stoke?

31st July 2007

Do you ever feel that you are banging your head against a brick wall? That no-one else can be bothered when you are making an effort to do something? That whatever you do is stymied because other people are just too afraid of the consequences if they stick their head above the parapet?

You never have had this feeling? Try asking our elected (and unelected) representatives on the Stoke-on-Trent City Council to respond to a simple question. It is dispiriting, and totally unacceptable, that of the nineteen e-mails sent to our representatives, replies have been received from two - and one of these was abusive.

What has happened to the principles of Democracy in Stoke-on-Trent?
  • that the elected representatives of the people are responsible to their electorate?
  • that no undue influence is placed on elected representatives by outside bodies or other elected representatives?
  • that elected bodies are open and transparent?
  • that there is freedom of speech, debate and enquiry?
In a democracy, every citizen has certain basic rights that the state cannot take away. These rights are internationally recognised and guaranteed: 
  • everyone has the right to have their own beliefs, including their religious beliefs, and to say and write what they think.
  • everyone has the right to seek different sources of information and ideas.
  • everyone has the right to associate with other people, and to form and join organisations of their own choice. 
  • everyone has the right to assemble and to protest government actions.
However, citizens have an obligation to exercise these rights peacefully, with respect for the law and for the rights of others. The Hands off Haywood High Community Group respects, and will always respect, its obligation in this regard.

Government must be open and accountable to the public about its actions. It must allow the public to give input before decisions are taken.

Anybody who attempts to suppress legitimate political debate should be suspected of trying to defend illegitimate power. Government, local or national, is the servant of the people, not their master. Its job is to listen to, respond to and deliver that which is demanded by the people.

People have a right and a duty to participate in government and in civil society. Public participation includes standing for elections, voting in elections, becoming informed, holding and attending community meetings, joining civil and/or political organisations, paying taxes, protesting and petitioning.

Elected representatives at both national and local levels (including Stoke-on-Trent) must listen to the people and be responsive to their needs and wishes. Has it occurred to our representatives that the Council's lack of responsiveness may be a large part of the reason that so few people exercise their democratic right to take part in the electoral process, quite rightly thinking that nothing will change no matter for whom they vote? Maybe this fact suits certain vested interests.

Stoke-on-Trent City Council, which is so blatant in its failure to live up to its own slogan "Putting People First", should remember the following: the people are sovereign, NOT those who have been elected or appointed - they, the people, are the highest authority, upon whose will government is based.

The status quo in Stoke-on-Trent is that we are ruled by a self-imposed oligarchy (viz. the Elected Mayor's cabinet, which excludes many shades of political opinion). If the rules have been legitimately changed, and we no longer live in a democracy, will someone please tell us!!

Save Our School
It may just be a total coincidence,
but we would like to think otherwise.


The following press release appeared on the Stoke-on-Trent City Council website:


35-08

Council asks people for their views on budget

Local people to have their say on new budget
6.30pm Thursday 31 January, King's Hall, Stoke

For the first time ever the people of Stoke-on-Trent are invited to have their say on how the city council's new budget for 2008/09 will be allocated at a Budget Summit on Thursday.

Councillor Michael Tappin, portfolio holder for Resources, said: "This is about transparency - which we promised we would provide - and it's also about empowering and strengthening neighbourhoods to have their say and take more control of spending in their communities.

"Stoke-on-Trent isn't a 'one size fits all' city so there's no point in producing a 'one size fits all' budget.  Local people know best what they need - not local government staff sitting behind desks.  We want to involve people from the business community, residents, the voluntary sector, young people, older people - anyone and everyone. Because this is their city - and it's their budget."

The Budget Summit, at 6.30pm on Thursday 31 January at the King's Hall, Kingsway, Stoke, will give people the chance to discuss budget priorities with Councillor Tappin, Elected Mayor Mark Meredith, Chief Executive Steve Robinson and the city council's Director of Central Services Julie Gill.

People will also be asked to contribute their ideas on the most effective way that the £4.5 million from the sale of Britannia Stadium shares should be invested in Stoke.

There will be feedback sheets to make sure people can give their views should they not get the chance to speak to the panel on the night

Twenty exhibition stands will display from 2 pm showing some of the services the budget is responsible for funding and informing people who may be interested in becoming a councillor.

Ref Code:35-08

Contact:

For more information please contact Martin Watkins on 01782 232671.

Issued: 28 January 2008.


O.K., so it was issued on the 28th January for a meeting on 31st January, giving little time for people to plan ahead, but it's a step in the right direction.

May we draw your attention to the following quote: "This is about transparency - which we promised we would provide - and it's also about empowering and strengthening neighbourhoods to have their say ... ".

The interesting point is that our pages on community empowerment went online on the 23rd and 24th January.

Coincidence
or may we claim just a little credit?

Save Our School